Has the Budget Done Enough for Pubs and Breweries?
Key Takeaways
- Ash Corbett-Collins and Andy Slee joined host Martin to analyze the real-world impact of the latest government Budget on independent breweries and pubs.
- Access to market remains the single biggest hurdle for independent brewers struggling to get their products onto pub bars through tied systems.
- The newly proposed guest beer provision could create vital opportunities for local brewers, provided the regulatory details are handled correctly.
- Despite recent high-profile closures of major cask producing sites, cask ale retains a passionate following and significant growth potential among younger demographics.
- Industry leaders emphasize that ordinary beer drinkers hold real power by simply asking their local pubs to stock independent beers.
- Campaigners are pushing for British cask ale to be officially recognised as intangible cultural heritage to better protect the nation's brewing traditions.
What does the latest Budget actually mean for independent breweries, pubs and beer drinkers?
This week on The Beer Rep Chats With, I’m joined by Ash Corbett-Collins, Chairman of CAMRA, and Andy Slee, CEO of SIBA, for a wide-ranging conversation about the state of the UK beer industry.
We start with the Budget and whether the measures announced will genuinely help independent breweries and pubs, including small producer relief (SPR), business rates and the introduction of a guest beer provision.
But it quickly becomes clear that the bigger issue is access to market.
We talk about why independent breweries can still struggle to get their beer onto pub bars, the problems surrounding tied beer lines and dispense equipment, and why getting the detail of the new guest beer provision right could be crucial.
We also discuss the future of cask ale, particularly following the closure announcements around major brewing sites including Marston's, Sharp's and Banks. Is cask beer really in decline, or is the problem that too little investment has gone into selling and supporting it?
Ash argues that there is a future for cask, including among younger drinkers, while Andy highlights the opportunity for independent brewers if the market gives them access to the hand pulls needed to sell it.
We also get into the campaign for cask ale to be recognised as intangible cultural heritage, what that could mean in practice, and why both guests believe Britain's brewing heritage deserves greater protection.
Towards the end of the conversation, we turn to campaigning and ask what CAMRA and SIBA can realistically do to influence government, why fact-based conversations matter more than simply shouting on social media, and what ordinary beer drinkers can actually do to help.
And their message is surprisingly simple, ask your pub for the independent beer you want to drink.
Because, as both Ash and Andy explain, demand exists. The challenge is making sure the industry has the conditions it needs to meet that demand.
A big thank you to Ash and Andy for coming on the show.
And, as always, thanks for listening.
The Beer Rep Chats With is proudly sponsored by The Keg Warehouse.
CAMRA Website:
SIBA Website:
CHAPTERS
00:00 The Budget and the State of Independent Beer
03:10 What the Budget Means for Drinkers and Pubs
05:53 Why the Detail Behind Guest Beer Matters
11:43 SIBA Beerflex and Getting Independent Beer Into Pubs
14:55 Cask Ale Can Grow when Pubs Invest in Quality
20:13 Why Global Brewers Deprioritise Uniquely British Cask
27:50 What a Fairer Beer Market Could Look Like
34:42 Cask as Cultural Heritage, Not Just A Product
43:14 Why The Access To Market Review Is Taking So Long
48:50 Why Cask Beer Is Under More Threat Than Ever
56:04 What Can Beer Drinkers Actually Do?
1:02:47 A Hopeful Closing: Decline is not Inevitable
See more at beerrepchats.com
Frequently Asked Questions
What does the Budget mean for independent breweries in the UK?
The Budget contains some measures that could help independent breweries, including support for small producers through beer duty and changes around guest beer. However, Ash Corbett-Collins of CAMRA and Andy Slee of SIBA argue that these measures do not resolve the industry's larger structural problems, particularly access to market, taxation and rising operating costs.
What is the biggest problem facing independent breweries?
According to Andy Slee, the two major barriers to growth repeatedly raised by SIBA's members are access to market and high levels of taxation. The discussion argues that independent breweries can have demand for their beer but still struggle to get it into pubs and other outlets.
Is cask beer really in decline in the UK?
Andy Slee & Ash Corbett-Collins strongly reject the idea that cask beer itself is dying. Their argument is that poorly supported and under-invested cask brands may be struggling, while demand for good independent cask beer remains strong.
Why is cask beer described as uniquely British?
Andy Slee argues that cask beer is unique to Britain and therefore has a particular cultural and heritage value. The episode discusses whether recognising cask ale as intangible cultural heritage could help change the way government and the public think about protecting it.
What can beer drinkers do to support independent breweries?
Andy Slee's advice is simple: ask your local pub for your favourite independent beer and ask why it isn't available. Ash also encourages people to contact their MPs, support campaigns and, even more simply, talk to other beer drinkers about the issues affecting independent beer.
Will guest beer help independent breweries?
Potentially, but Ash Corbett-Collins and Andy Slee both stress that the details will be crucial. They discuss concerns around how guest beer will work in practice, including financial penalties, existing tied arrangements and the possibility that the measure could have less impact than its headline suggests if the underlying market restrictions remain.
Martin (00:00)
Hello and welcome to another episode of the Beer Rep chats with and proudly sponsored by the Keg warehouse. So we've just had the budget come out and let's have a, have a little talk about how it's affected the industry as a whole. Today I'm proudly joined by Ash Corbett-Collins from CAMRA and Andy Slee of SIBA Thanks very much for joining us.
Andy Slee (00:25)
Pleasure
Ash Corbett-Collins (00:26)
Yeah, thanks.
Martin (00:27)
No problem. So let's get into it. Let's get into the nitty gritty. has this budget really helped independent breweries and pubs and are there kind of underlying problems still?
Ash Corbett-Collins (00:39)
Andy, do you want to first?
Andy Slee (00:40)
Yeah, yeah,
yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah. So I think a couple of, a couple of ones. So first of all, let's look at it at a hospitality level because SIBA represents 700 independent brewers. We run two and a half thousand pubs, and taprooms and 80 % of what we sell is sold into the hospitality trade. So their health is really important to us as well.
So a couple of elements of surprise there. There was no surprise in my mind that the government did nothing on VAT because that was a huge ask and it would have, you know, let's be honest, it would have benefited Starbucks and Costas more than it would have affected the independent pub. That's something I pointed out over the summer. So that wasn't a surprise.
There was a surprise that the government didn't do anything directly on national insurance and helping hospitality businesses employ more people. On the back of the Alan Milburn review of that there are one million 18 to 24 year olds who are neither in education or in any sort of training. So that was a surprise. There was some welcome news on business rates.
in actually moving another several, I think it was 5,000 pubs above the threshold for business rates. And again, that helps them as well. That's good. And obviously the two bits of news for independent brewing were firstly, the 10 million pound help on beer duty for small producers of all sorts. And then the news on guest beer as well, the guest beer announcement.
Martin (02:33)
Yeah, definitely.
Andy Slee (02:34)
So they're the two big bits of news that affect us directly. maybe Ash wants to comment further on those.
Ash Corbett-Collins (02:45)
Yeah, sure. So, you know, obviously as Andy says, he he sort represents the one side of the bar and in when it comes to hospitality and CAMRA represents that other side. And and budgets are always really difficult for us because as pubgoers and drinkers, when the budget comes around, a lot of our members say, Well, actually, what's it going to mean for me as a drinker, as a pubgoer, you know, at at the point of sale, when I buy my beer, what's going to change based on this budget? And I I can't remember the last time a budget particularly had much of a a very direct positive impact.
On drinkers, just because of the nature of what budgets are. They're focused at business level. so you know, for us it was a mixed bag. And I think when I posted to my own social medias about the budget, I very much use, you smiley face for some things, neutral face for others, and sad face for some of them all. Because yeah, it it some of the things I've announced, as Andy said, will be helpful when we think about what our members are asking for, which to be able to get more quality independent beer on the bar and be able to choose it and to keep beer affordable.
Some of those measures will help. This potential guest beer right, if done correctly, could help. That draft relief for small brewers could help. But then the announcements on duty going up and you know, we've still got things like access to market from a budget two budgets ago, not quite done. I think,
Martin (04:00)
Minimum wage.
Ash Corbett-Collins (04:01)
yeah, you know, it it's all, you know, it's deck chairs on the Titanic almost. The the average drinker, I don't think, is going to see a particular difference. They bit well, not a positive difference.
The beer's going to get a little bit more expensive, almost certainly, based on what's been announced. They might see some independent beer on there. Ultimately, you know, as Andy talked about, if some of these measures can help independent brewers and publicans to survive and hopefully start to thrive, that will have a benefit for consumers. But yeah, I think sort of post-budget, our immediate reaction was oh.
Martin (04:30)
Yeah. It was good in some areas and not so good in other areas. And it's probably not going to make much difference. Let's touch a bit on the guest beer provision that's been brought into the pubs code in England, Wales, finally, after it been trialled in Scotland for over a year now, probably. Could this obviously give independent breweries better access to the pub market or is there, you know, it's getting that detail right? I mean, how is it going to...
How, how are the pubco's going to accept this? How the publicans going to be able to apply for a guest beer line and is it going to be a long winded process? are they going to get kind of, mean, I've heard of, area managers and pubco's kind of bribing the tenants to say, well, you could apply for this, but it's going to kind of harm your, lease in the future. I mean, should there be some sort of legalised action in the pubs code to
like bypass all this.
Andy Slee (05:30)
I think it's a good question. The honest answer is what's it going to look like? We don't know. And when's it going to come? We don't know that either. So I think Ash is right. Two budgets ago, the government announced a review of how independent brewers could gain better access to all parts of the beer market, which we welcomed at the time. And we worked with industry colleagues and the Department of Business.
to work through ways of that. So one of the immediate concerns is that the access to market as announced doesn't cover what goes on in the free trade, for example, in free houses. It doesn't cover proprietary dispense equipment by that mean, dispense equipment owned by global brewers, where only their beers can be served. So that's not covered.
So the honest truth is that we need to work through with the Department of Business what they have in mind, where they're going to be, what the implementation timeline is. come back to our brewers talk to us all the time about the two main barriers for growth is one is access to market and secondly is high levels of taxation. And this tackles part of one of those and
the ongoing, maybe we'll touch on taxation, come back to taxation a little bit later on. unfortunately, I can't throw any more light on what the guest beer might bring to us.
Martin (07:11)
Yeah, so pretty much we need a bit more detail before we can kind of act on that. Ash, do want to add anything to that?
Ash Corbett-Collins (07:17)
Yeah, I I think that's absolutely right. You know, the devil is in the detail on this. my worry is a lot of I think the general public and and potentially decision makers understanding of the industry is fixed in time to about 1989 when I'm gonna say the the buzzword the beer orders happened.
Martin (07:35)
Yes.
Ash Corbett-Collins (07:35)
and I think people you know, if you talk to Joe Bloggs in the pub, they're gonna talk to you about, yeah, these tied houses, tied to breweries, all this sort stuff. Exactly how the traditional pub model was, but actually
hasn't really existed as the predominant model since before I was born. I wasn't even alive in 1989. So this sort of the industry
Martin (07:53)
Lucky you.
Ash Corbett-Collins (07:56)
has very much moved on. And Andy's absolutely right that we've got what I think the general public would recognise as a free house, isn't operating under what the general public would expect a free house to be able to operate as, which is to stock whatever they want, however they want, to serve the public what they want.
When we saw micropubs sort of explode after the the change of planning laws what about two decades ago almost? And they came out and they sort of immediately demonstrated that if a venue is allowed to serve exactly what the public wants, often they do very well because they get the beer directly in and they can serve it. what we worry about in terms of this guest beer right is as we talked about, if it's not implemented correctly, if it's done based on a model that doesn't exist, if it is done haphazardly or quickly or sort of as a
a headline and isn't that great and we fixed this problem. But it doesn't because underlying all that is are publicans forced to pay certain amounts. You know, we know that in the industry, if you buy a beer that isn't that you're tied to in some way, sometimes you're having to pay extraordinary amounts for it, or you are financially
penalised for serving something that isn't your tied beer. So they'll, you know, we know of instances where the publican can serve
X brew from the local brewery, but as long as you serve so many pints or earn generate so much revenue based on the other one, otherwise there's a there's a penalty to it. So there's all these sort of things that happen underneath that make it so much more complicated than just saying, well, we're gonna let publicans be able to stock a guest beer. Because what we have to remember is those with vested interest in this will not just let that happen quietly. They will get very expensive lawyers to find very
complicated ways of avoiding all of this or making sure that when it's implemented, it's implemented in way that is as little impact to their bottom line as possible and so on. And then Andy's absolutely right. I always think about one of the local breweries near me, Indian Brewery, and they talk about this access to market that we think is fundamental as an organisation that needs to be looked at.
I went and visited them. They're, you know, they've got this massive unit in in Jewelry Quarter in Birmingham. They've spent a lot of money on building a humongous brewery. It's incredibly popular as a venue. Their beers are great. They, you know, they want to generate growth in Birmingham and employment, all this sort of stuff, and and brew good beer. and I I said
yeah, and I said to them, I said, Well, you how how is business? How's particularly getting your beers out there? And the fundamental thing they said was they can't really get their beer in Birmingham. They can't sell
it.
to the trade because that market is tied up. It is impossible for them. And we've got you down in Stirchley way here as well, three, four breweries down that way which are doing fantastic beers, cask and keg, and they're brilliant and they're trying things and there's quality and there's passion. And you do see them out and about, but not as much as you should. Not as much as the public in Birmingham and the wider West Midlands want to see these beers and want to be able to buy these beers. And without that access to market, those brilliant breweries will struggle and ultimately might close because of it.
Martin (10:53)
Yeah, I mean, Andy, you've got,
yeah, Siba's got a, beer flex that you, introduced, you work with a few pubco's, for independent breweries to get access into these pubs. Do you think it'd be good for the government to kind of work with you guys to kind of enforce that, across the whole of the UK and Wales and Scotland for the pubco's then to go through you guys so that the independent breweries don't get, you know, shafted.
Andy Slee (11:20)
It's certainly one of the options. at this point, I'd like to call out particularly Green King, who are without question the most supportive of that Beerflex scheme. So we have independent beers in approaching half of their pubs across the UK via Beerflex. And they embrace it and they see the opportunity in having our beer alongside global brands.
You know, and what we talk about is not taking over the bar and only being independent beer. there's a really broad beer market. There's a demand for, you know, the well-known global brands, just as there's a demand for independent beer. And actually, you sell more as a publican when you pander to both markets and
Martin (12:11)
Close.
Andy Slee (12:13)
that's some that's a message that sometimes lost. think there's another dynamic that's come into this.
in the last few weeks, which is really important. And that's the closure of Marston's by Carlsberg. with it that,
Martin (12:26)
Yeah, we're just about to touch on that one.
Andy Slee (12:27)
yeah, with that, that's the loss of the biggest cask beer brewer in the UK. Now, the challenge facing independent brewers for that is that by the time that Carlsberg closes Marston's, independent brewers will be brewing the vast majority of the cask beer in the UK.
but will own
Martin (12:49)
with no access.
Andy Slee (12:51)
will only own about 10 to 15 percent of the hand pumps. so certain of the global brewers were indifferent to that hand pump when they were brewing cask beer So when they're not brewing it, what's going to happen then? And what ought to be the case? And I've seen some stuff from.
from Carlsberg that say that this presents a really good opportunity for independent beer, and it does, but only if the market conditions are right. Without stating the obvious, you can only sell cask beer through a hand pull, and if the hand pull has been taken out, then it's much more difficult. So that's one of the things we're talking about.
Martin (13:33)
It is, especially if you
haven't got like a walk in access to your cellar where you can do it direct from the cask, know, by gravity, Yeah. So there's hardly any, any pubs that have that.
Andy Slee (13:40)
Hmm. Which, and they admit that's minimal amount. Yeah, So the markup of the... Yeah, yeah.
Martin (13:47)
So yeah, we'll talk about the closures of the breweries. know, Sharps is facing closure this year completely. Obviously you talk about Marston's in Burton, they're facing closure next year.
And Banks is already closed in Wolverhampton. So what do these developments tell us about the priorities of the big brewing groups for the future of cask ale? I mean, obviously they're kind of dropping their cask ale range. So obviously a clear, that means that independents need to step in and the government needs to make sure that the independents can sell their cask beer in these pubs.
Yeah, Ash, wanna
pick up on that one?
Ash Corbett-Collins (14:31)
So yeah, I
I think what we as an organisation are are rejecting very roundly is cask beer market is not dying. And that is what these global brewers, when they've come along and they've bought up these traditional brewers and then they you know after several years and say, Well, you know, it's struggling, we can't sell it and that market's just not for us anymore. And we reject that. firstly
we don't like as well, what always seems to be pushed is, well, it you know, CAMRA just wants to fix in time and stick with tradition and they just want to go back to 1971 when cask beer was everywhere. And it's not true. We know that cask beer, when it can be sold, when independent breweries can get it on the bar, it can do really well. But we know that space on the bar is limited and we know that where it is on the bar it's being taken up by a lot of these globals, pushing out a product that is not quality. If you're going to buy up traditional brewers
slowly but surely manage the decline of the quality of it and frankly don't put a lot of effort into it at the point of sale, in terms of training staff, in terms of making sure your product is quality, well then no wonder at the end of that, people just choose not to purchase that product anymore. But when we see the opposite happen, when we see you know, Bass at the point of sale, they put that huge sort of I forgot the word, money. That's about investment. That's the that's
Martin (15:51)
You
Ash Corbett-Collins (15:52)
the polite term.
They put investment into the the point of sale for Bass. They made a big push of it to get it out there across the country. Now, that's not actually a lot of effort what they did. They you know, they put some money behind it, some snazzy new graphics and just traded back on the fact that Bass is a historically important beer. But the moment that happened, sales went through the roof. It is the fastest growing cask brand in this country through just a little effort and making sure that the product's okay. Now we know if every global brewer and every regional brewer did that, that cask would be fine.
Because if consumers could get a good beer on the bar that they enjoy, they will go out and buy them. There are other factors, you know, the increasing costs and and pubs just struggling to survive, you know, once you lose those, well, there's no cask because there's no pub. But all things being equal and an ideal, good quality cask will sell. And we know that. We know when we talk to our members, when we talk to non-members, we know that. And the other thing as well is people say, well, you know, old people drink cask. Well, actually, Gen Z are drinking cask in
Significant numbers is the word I'd use.
Martin (16:51)
Yeah.
Ash Corbett-Collins (16:52)
So I think as a percentage, it's something like 7% of Gen Z are drinking cask, which sounds small. And it is small, it's not particularly massive. But my generation, when we were 18 to 24, 2 or 3% of us were drinking cask. So Gen Z are already
Martin (17:04)
Yeah.
Ash Corbett-Collins (17:05)
drinking it two or three times as much as my generation were. My generation now, when we're into our mid thirties, I think about 20% of us are drinking cask. So
Martin (17:12)
Yeah.
Ash Corbett-Collins (17:12)
if you sort of follow that and say, well, if Gen Z, if we put the effort in and market cask beer to them as a viable product they'll enjoy,
That they're already enjoying in significant numbers, maybe we'll get 30, 40% of Gen Z drinking cask at that point in kind of 10, 15 years. So there's not only potential now, there is a future for cask if it is invested in, as well as all the other fantastic beers. Obviously, we're not only cask. Brilliant keg by independent brewers is good as well, because as Andy said, you know, once you've got all those beers on the bar, if you've got global brands on the bar, if you've got genuine quality independent on the bar and all the other things in between, that's what makes a successful pub.
Martin (17:48)
Yeah, think that cask for me, especially when I was young, it's kind of an entry level to beer, isn't it? When you're young, because it's probably priced at a lower margin than your keg option. A student would always go to a cask because it's X amount pounds cheaper than a keg option maybe. And it was always an entry level for younger drinkers to drink cask beer. And then they kind of develop their tastes and, you know, the more money they earned as they got older, they broaden their range a bit more.
And yeah, it's always been that for me.
Ash Corbett-Collins (18:20)
Yeah, and
Andy Slee (18:20)
I
can't just... No, no, no, after you Ash.
Ash Corbett-Collins (18:22)
I'll be sorry, Andy, you go. I I
I was just gonna say, you know, cask it's a fantastic entry. when I was that sort of age, I remember trying a few of sort of the lagers that my friends wanted to drink and then I was like, this isn't really for me. And then I found cask and oh yeah, brilliant, this is actually the sort of beer I want to drink. And I think one of the struggles is reputation. And we'll put the we'll have said there, the globals produce sort of crap beer.
That they're then put in cask and then a publican is sort of forced to serve it, say, right, you've got to take one of our sort of national brands and we'll do you a deal on X and Y and Z. And it sits there in the corner of the bar and no one really drinks it and it turns to vinegar. And then that entry-level person comes in and says, I'll have a cask, it's a bit cheaper. And then they go, my god, is that what it's supposed to be? That that's one of the huge problems. Yeah. Yeah. And then they'll go, this is horrible. Is this what you know all those people are drinking?
Martin (19:06)
tastes more like a sour than a...
Ash Corbett-Collins (19:11)
And it's not what those people are drinking, but the category is being undermined.
by that lack of investment, that lack of training, that lack of care in it. And and it ultimately then comes across in terms of I saw a politician recently describe British beer as being warm and flat. And I think my heart sinks every time I read those sort of words because cask beer, good cask beer, is not warm and it's not flat. It's just not as fizzy and not as cold. But the warm and flat makes you think of something quite undesirable in a beer. So we've got this whole reputational risk that, you know, is gonna undermine the market.
but actually the globals have the opportunity to fix that.
Andy Slee (19:50)
I've just got bit of a bit of insight that previously in my career, I worked for the world's largest soft drinks manufacturer for 12 years. I used to look after sales to the on premise. So brands like Appletizer and Monster and, Schweppes and that kind of stuff. And that gives you insight into how global drinks businesses view markets.
they're only interested in products that have got an international dimension and that they can export and there's a and you're always judged about the name above the door. So if you're Carlsberg, you're judged on how Carlsberg sales are going principally. And what that means is products that are uniquely unique to a particular country fall way down the pecking order.
And the thing that's often forgotten with cask beer is that it's unique to Britain. It's only done here. You can't get it anywhere else. it's very obvious for those of us in the industry who are passionate about it or earn a living from it. But actually to the general public, that isn't always obvious. And so that's why it's really important that we protect it. When I speak to brewers from abroad,
The first thing they want to talk to me about is cask beer and how we do it and what the heritage is and all this kind of stuff. they also in terms of appeal to to younger drinkers. And I always use this analogy. Imagine for a second we weren't talking about beer. We were talking about sausages and we were talking about a product that was fresh, was served in recyclable containers.
that was uniquely British and had really good green mile because generally they're consumed close to the point of production. If you were talking about sausages, you would be talking about a premium in price over mass produced sausages. And they're the sort of things that younger consumers are all over. That's what appeals to them in other categories. those sort of things.
are the appeal for cask beer as well as being uniquely British. And I think that's why younger drinkers are coming towards them, because it is for me it is all beers good, but it's the best form of beer is cask beer because it's fresh and when it's good, when it's good, it is magnificent. Yeah, it is And
Martin (22:26)
beautiful. It is beautiful.
Ash Corbett-Collins (22:27)
Mm.
Andy Slee (22:28)
to back what ash says is the work that Inbev have done on draft bass, you know,
Draft bass is owned by the biggest brewer in the world. The level of investment that they've given draft bass is big, but in their terms, it's loose change behind the sofa. And a little bit of effort. And look what's happened. I'd also counter really strongly when people say to me, cask beer is dying. I would say absolutely not. Unloved, uninvested.
cask beer brands by global brewers are dying. But actually demand for independent cask beer is really strong. It's going up.
Martin (23:16)
Yeah, 100%.
Andy Slee (23:18)
You only have to go to any town in the UK and look at how busy a taproom, their taproom is in any town in the UK. And you go past pubs with, you know, this pub for rent or boarded up pubs, and you go to taprooms where business is thriving to see that.
And what we can't allow is that that cask beer by that the hand pull ownership issue I talked about earlier cask beer becomes ghettoized and forced into into relatively small amounts of beer. It should be available in more outlets and there is absolutely demand for it. I'll look anyone in the eyes and argue passionately for that as I do on a regular basis. Absolutely.
Martin (24:00)
Yeah, think we all would.
Ash Corbett-Collins (24:03)
Just want touch on what Andy said there about the the ownership of hand pulls. we've had a conversation with a brewer recently who wanted to introduce a non-cask beer, which is fine in general, but what they want to do was put it on on the cask handpulls. and CAMRA's position is that no cask handpulls have to be reserved for cask conditioned beer. That's what the consumer expects, that's what they want. It's very important they get that. And it's a very slippery slope if that is changed.
And politely made our position to this brewery and they came back and they explained their reasoning a bit more. And what they said to us were they said, well, we can't get on the kegs. The kegs lines are already all spoken for. The globals absolutely have got those wrapped up. But what we can do is we can get onto some of the cask handpulls Now I can see as a business why that to them makes sense, but I think that's sort of getting a short term benefit. Great, you need to sell a bit more of that, but it's taking that future away from cask. Because Andy says, you know.
If you start reducing it and ghettoising and and it's not available everywhere as it should be, and everyone sees, well, actually we can just take all these ready made handpulls that people already like and use those for different types of beer, well then cask just keeps getting undermined. So that's so important to us. And and the other thing is talking about that price point. I think we've mentioned it a few times, and that's why the budget's so important. We know as an organisation that many of our members value the price of a pint. And I'll be very careful because what they value is I'm gonna keep using that word, value for money.
People, you know, that is what every decision you ever buy something on is based upon value for money. And yeah. People have to think about
Martin (25:32)
we're in a cost of living crisis. So it makes it even more important, doesn't it
Ash Corbett-Collins (25:36)
yeah, where those pennies are going and they want something that's worth it when they pay for it. And as an organisation, again, as members, we don't begrudge brewers and publicans making a living from this. We appreciate that ingredients have to go into it. We appreciate people have to make a living out of it. I'm still yet to particularly meet anyone who's got rich from being a brewer or Republican, unless they're very
Martin (25:54)
you
Ash Corbett-Collins (25:54)
unscrupulous.
These are all just passionate people, in some instances making barely minimum wage when they sort of add it all up at the end of the day. But these are all costs. And Andy's talked about national insurance contribution, all these sort thing. So as an organisation, we know that and I think as drinkers, we all know that people are counting where their money goes in their wallet, and we know they want to spend that money wisely. And what we needed from this budget was when all the things that can't really be done by the government, you know, they can't really set a price of raw ingredients, stuff like that.
But they can talk about duty, they can talk about business rates they can talk about taxation in general, these national insurance, all the other bits, and we used to produce a graphic where it shows your pint and it sort of adds up, and I think the actual beer and running the pub was probably a slither of it. The levers that the government had to pull to keep the price of a pint affordable just haven't been pulled in a way that we think is going to benefit brewers, publicans or the pub goers at this stage.
Martin (26:48)
Yeah, I saw a recent
Andy Slee (26:48)
Yeah, I think this.
Martin (26:50)
post from James Cleverley doing that pint thing where he was drinking a pint and then telling you exactly how much of that goes where and I was just okay. Okay. Where was you five years ago?
Ash Corbett-Collins (26:59)
Yeah. Well, yeah, that's what I was gonna say. It was very convenient that that
you know, the opposition, no matter what colour the rosette, always finds ways to say how much they love pubs and and isn't it terrible what's being done, just as soon as they're no longer making the decisions on it.
Martin (27:13)
Exactly
that. Yeah, it's a noise made, but I'm sure it annoys everyone. So let's get back onto, you know, how independent breweries can kind of pick up that, cask beer in pubs. What would be the best way of them doing that? You know, what can the government do to help that make it be realistic?
Andy Slee (27:34)
So I think I'll go back to the access to market review that was kicked off a couple of years ago, because that went across the whole of the market and it included cask and keg. That was a really important part of that discussion. So I've yet to meet a publican that wouldn't like a competitor to Guinness, for example, you know, if they could get it. And so how do you get the keg? There are some...
absolutely wonderful independent lagers brewed by our members.
Martin (28:07)
loads.
Andy Slee (28:07)
Stunning, stunning lagers that can't get access. So I think we need to see what that review had in mind and how we can increase the transparency around how dispense equipment works in the on-trade for the benefit. again, I'll stress to any global brewer that might be listening to this,
This isn't about indie beer independent brewers taking over the world. This is about how can we coexist alongside each other? So the demand for both is met. So I think that's a really important part of the discussion. And a subset of that is the discussion around what the government has in mind on guest beer. And we will keep talking to government on that to understand what the details are around that.
Martin (28:57)
Yeah, definitely. And so on top of that, we've got additional business rates relief for pubs, rising to 35 % or something from April 27. And that's really welcome, I suppose, you know, because the publicans are dealing with staff costs, energy bills, etc. tax and stuff.
Customers are watching every penny now with the alcohol duty set to rise in February 27. So, you know, is that a welcome relief? Is it going to do much to the hospitality sector in general? is it kind of, kind of balanced out with all the rises in costs?
Andy Slee (29:41)
The thing we haven't mentioned is a rise in energy costs because they will be the biggest increase. What's
Martin (29:47)
Yeah.
Andy Slee (29:47)
going on in the Middle East war? We've got the American midterms tomorrow as we're recording this and Lord knows what's going to happen with that and what Trump's reaction to that's going to be. So
Martin (29:59)
Yeah.
Andy Slee (30:00)
there's a whole lot of uncertainty. My sense actually in the whole budget was that the chancellor did lots of small things.
and was very wary that the world could change in the next two
Martin (30:15)
course
Andy Slee (30:16)
to three weeks. So I think there's an awful lot of uncertainty. The thing that keeps me going when I wake up in the morning is the passion that I know that there is strong demand for independent beer. And actually turnover and demand isn't an issue
for independent beers, making money is. it's the increasing costs, is the taxation and getting products into more outlets are the three things that mean we'll more survive. In 2025, we lost two breweries a week in the UK. So we lost over 100 breweries. That rate of closure seems to have slowed this year, which is welcome.
But we're talking about that position being less bad, not good. And we
Martin (31:11)
Yeah, exactly.
Andy Slee (31:13)
want to make sure that Britain's brewing heritage is returned. Our breweries are the ones that are located in the communities. We employ people in the local area. We support suppliers in the vicinity of the brewery, typically. And we have connections to local communities. All the things that pubs are, they do in spades.
If the government want growth in every postcode in the UK, there's an independent brewery pretty much in every postcode. So we can really play to that growth agenda alongside in our colleagues in the pub sector.
Martin (31:50)
100% Ash, wanna add to that?
Ash Corbett-Collins (31:53)
yeah, I completely agree. I think post budget what I noticed was no one was particularly happy. And and Andy's absolutely right that there's so many big matters going on that there's so little actually sometimes a government can do. And it's almost I have some sympathy for the Chancellor and other people in the cabinet sort of almost having to swim against a tide at this stage and they've got no decision making power on which way the water goes or how powerful it is, they just have to keep swimming and hope the head stays above water.
So I I
Martin (32:22)
Yeah.
Ash Corbett-Collins (32:22)
get it, but you know, Publicans, brewers and pub goers are part of what they are, they can make decisions on. So I think the budget was disappointing for them. is probably the nice way of saying it. I have seen people be much more kind of angry, maybe in their language around it, because it did feel like you know, one step forward with some of the measures, it's two steps back with some of the other things announced.
What I also find incredibly frustrating is the simplification of this, because Andy's right about talking about all those big complex matters and so where costs are increasing here, there and everywhere, that can't be controlled and other things that can be controlled and that have been done, haven't been done. And then what you get is a headline at the end of it that says Chancellor announces 2p on every pint. Now the Chancellor did not announce 2p on every pint because that's just simply not how Beer Duty works.
And if I could, you know, if I had a magic wand, I would make everyone in the country understand that beer duty is not a tax that is paid at the point of sale immediately on your pint. And so all those years beforehand, when governments get to say, 1p off a pint, they'd say every year because they've frozen beer duty, whatever it was. And then we'd get our members come to me and say, Well, why is my beer not 1p cheaper? And then I have to spend time explaining, well, because raw ingredients are more expensive, utilities are more expensive, national insurance went up, business rates went up.
The price you pay for your pint isn't just some fixed cost that they add a little bit of VAT on at the end. Well, they do add a bit of VAT on the end, but that that's such a small matter. So beer duty
Martin (33:44)
Yeah. Yeah. Yeah.
Ash Corbett-Collins (33:48)
is not like that. And all these things, they happen together. And so unless the sort of solution is found in a holistic way, in looking at the whole industry, at this access to market, at the taxation, at the business rates, at the national, you have to look at it all together. You can't say, Well, I give them a little bit here with the, you know, one thing, but we took a little bit there with the other thing. It's sort of
at best cancels each other out, at worst you end up in a worse position because it wasn't thought of holistically.
Martin (34:16)
Yeah, 100%. Yeah.
Andy Slee (34:16)
Yeah.
Martin (34:18)
So we've recently seen parliament debate, recognising the production and serving of cask ale as intangible cultural heritage. The government has confirmed that the submission has been assessed. What would this recognition mean in practice and how could it help protect, you know, more closures of beer brands that just being taken over by a global, like you said earlier, and, you know, just making them
rot into the ground with no investment.
Ash Corbett-Collins (34:49)
I think first and foremost, it's about a mindset change. If you get that recognition of something that is so intrinsically important to Britain that is almost uniquely British, then it becomes a mindset change of what is it we're trying to protect. Because and these are all well worn sort of comparisons, but
France and champagne and Belgium and chocolate. And you know, every country has got one or two products that you associate it with and you sort of go, you know, if you visit there you have to try it, or if you buy it in a supermarket, you've got to get the best stuff, actual proper champagne. You can't get any sort of knock like you know, and people get very caught up on that. And again, that well worn sort of cliche is Britain seems to be the only country that doesn't seem to care about its unique exports and unique sort of traditions when it comes to these products like this.
Martin (35:37)
got pork pies.
Ash Corbett-Collins (35:39)
Yeah. Beer is
sort of just seen as like you know, just another thing. And it is interesting, a lot of our unique and traditional products are more working class, and I think there's almost a bit of a snobbery around that and people say, you know it's pasties pork pies and beers and whatever it is that, you know, Joe Bloggs has down the pub in 1955 seems to be. But it's not because these are brilliant artisanal products and and a very good pasty and a very good pork pie, not personally for me, but and very good beer, all sort of
You know, they don't have to be for a certain demographic, they're for everyone, they can be brilliant, they can be really quality. So I think the first thing is if you get that protection, it recognises that this isn't just a transactional product that's produced in a factory somewhere and pumped out and which is I think the mindset we have, which is when it comes to and maybe people who argue back against, why do we help pubs? Why do we help breweries? They're just drinking dens and and you know, they're you know, one on the corner of mine
roads full of ruffians and all these sort of things people say and they say the free market's fine and it works and and the bad pubs are closed. But because the mindset needs to change. We need to recognise that these are community assets, that these beers that they produce sorry that they sell that are being produced in this country by these independent local brewers are fantastic examples of what Britain has given the world and protecting it is so important. So I think that's the first thing. And then after that we can start building on that and having the conversations of saying okay we recognise we're protecting this we recognise the importance of it.
If we actually do something about it, what does that look like?
Martin (37:04)
Yeah, I
Andy Slee (37:05)
I compare how we approach brewing with Germany. So Germany has their enshrined purity laws and the headline rate of beer duty in Germany is 5p a pint In the UK it's 55p a pint post budget. It'll be 57, I think something like that. And that gives you a mindset of how the government sees brewing as part of the broader industrial strategy and its role in the community.
And can you imagine, to Ash's point earlier on, can you imagine in France somebody buying Moët & Chandon somebody from outside buying Moët & Chandon not investing in it and then turning it into a Riesling manufacturer and say, well, we're not, champagne's not for us anymore. Can you imagine that being allowed to happen? Could I count? Yeah, we're correct.
Martin (37:56)
be riots like they always is in France anyway but
Andy Slee (38:00)
Absolutely. But in terms of...
This is about protecting something that is uniquely British and part of our cultural heritage and really importantly, not because we want to keep a dying thing alive because we want to protect that. Say again, demand for it is strong. we need without stating the obvious, the only place you can drink cask beer is in the pub. So it's one thing.
that they sell in a pub, can't replicate at home. it's about protecting
Martin (38:37)
We've tried.
Andy Slee (38:39)
our heritage and making sure that it can continue and independent breweries can survive and thrive and again rebuild those connections into the future.
Martin (38:51)
Yeah, definitely. cask is definitely uniquely British. And the first thing that a tourist will come over to do is to try a traditional cask beer. If that doesn't make it more of a heritage to Britain, then I don't know what is, you know. if there was one thing you could ask the government, One further action to secure the future of independent breweries and pubs? What would it be?
One action, one action.
Andy Slee (39:22)
That's a question. I'm going to be very pragmatic now and say, right, can we see the output of the broader access to market review that you kicked off two years ago, which talks more broadly about how independent brewers and global brewers can better coexist for the benefit of everybody? I think that would be my one wish.
Martin (39:44)
Yeah, need a better free
market for everybody and not just for the proportion
Ash Corbett-Collins (39:51)
Yeah. And I think I agree with Andy. this is something that as an organisation and me personally have been pushing for, you know, since that budget two years ago when it was announced. Because so CAMRA we released our beer report earlier this year, which outlined exactly what we think are the problems in the industry, where we think consumers are being deceived, where we think brewers are not being given access to the market, where we believe that there are a whole host of reasons why what could be a very thriving industry is being strangled
Smothered by people who seek to undermine it and sort of protect their own interests, I would say. What we need and what sort of as an organisation, we can only go so far. We can only say, well, this is what all our members tell us, and this is what we see when we go and speak to other people in the industry, and this is what when we talk to publicans and brewers are telling us. But there is a whole host of information going under there. This is what we need that access to market to review to do. We believe that when it comes out, if the government has done their work properly, it will say.
Yes, we agree there is a fundamental issue with the market. That means consumers are not allowed to choose what they want when they want. That means brewers are not able to sell as they should be able to, that publicans can't serve as they should be able to. And that fundamentally that is causing the system to break. You know, and if we're talking in simple terms of a government that frankly is just trying to find where the money can be saved or made, I think that access to market report will say if it all worked.
There would be more money. There would, as Andy said, growth in every postcode because these pubs and brewers
Martin (41:18)
Yeah, there will be growth, yeah.
Ash Corbett-Collins (41:20)
would be employing more people and serving more beer because people vote with their wallets and as I said, it's smothered and strangled by people who aren't interested in the long-term future of cask, aren't interested in the long-term future of certain outlets. I would even question if some of those who are invested interest are even bothered about pubs, because for them they've got the off-trade. And I'm not against the off-trade. Our organisation isn't against the off-trade, but
Some of these organisations, when Andy was talking about, well, how much can you sell internationally? They're thinking just pure volume terms, well, we can get every supermarket in the land having slabs of our beers and every supermarket in the other countries across the world. And that for them is the ideal. But that's not the ideal for the consumer. The consumer wants choice. And so that access to market review has to come out and and say what we believe and what everyone in the country who's been to a pub recently will agree with.
I'd be very concerned if it comes out and says, No, everything's fixed, and it's fine, and this is how it's supposed to work, because that just tells me people don't understand the issue. But yeah, I think it really is. It'd be like saying that water's not wet or the sky isn't blue. Like it
Andy Slee (42:21)
It's inconceivable Ash, that it is inconceivable you say, yeah.
Ash Corbett-Collins (42:29)
you're you're sort of ignoring the evidence of your eyes and the wallet in the market if that was to be to be said. But yeah, step one, it's not a particularly exciting wish, you know, like Andy, it's pragmatic.
Give us that review first and then depending on what the review sort of says is if I could have a second wish I might then decide how to react to that access
to market review, depending on what they propose.
Martin (42:50)
Yeah. Do
you think it's taking so long because it's just so knotted and tangled that they haven't got a clue and there's not enough people in government that actually understand the whole issue with the access to market and the free market and how to fix it.
Ash Corbett-Collins (43:07)
I think
Andy Slee (43:08)
I
think the reality is that, as you say, this is a complex business to business issue. In essence, it's a business to business issue. But there is so much going on in the world. the simple truth is we've had seven prime ministers in the last 10 years. We had three prime ministers between 1979 and 2010, I think. So there's been an awful lot going on in the world.
And there's an awful lot of political upheaval. And, you know, by the time, you know, this gets to the top of somebody's in tray, then they may be moving on and you start the process again. think that
Martin (43:50)
Yeah.
Andy Slee (43:50)
that's the honest, the honest truth of it. It's not that they don't understand.
Martin (43:53)
bit more stability needed.
Andy Slee (43:55)
absolutely. So if there's more, there's more stability. What encourages me is that the Prime Minister and the Chancellor clearly understand hospitality.
And they've talked about wanting to support it in the broadest possible terms. The signal is that they're particularly fond of independent producers, which is good. And they've got lots of other issues I like to highlight it earlier on to deal with. It's just a matter of having somebody with enough time to put a damp towel over their head and
Martin (44:31)
Yeah.
Andy Slee (44:32)
actually understand the issues and then come out and...
we've said consistently, we'll happily work with the industry to whatever it comes out with, we'll work with the industry to come up with a solution that helps meet the goals. And that's not an issue from our perspective.
Martin (44:48)
Maybe
you or Ash can run for MP in your local constituent and then
Ash Corbett-Collins (44:52)
Yeah.
Martin (44:53)
speed it along a bit quicker.
Ash Corbett-Collins (44:55)
Yeah.
And and it's right, it's trying to convince people how important this is because there are so many competing priorities, and that is where organisations like CAMRA and SIBA and all the others come in, is we've got to use our collective voice to say, No, no, no, it's no matter how scary this issue is, you do have to deal with it. Because I think as long as I've been sort of a member of CAMRA and drinking, it's always been something that I think was quietly recognised but was thought of as
Well, we can put that on the back burner. Yes, pubs are closing. Yes, you know, consumer sales are going down, but they could point and say, Well, look at all these breweries that opened and look at all these micro pubs. And if we look at the industry as a whole, it makes a lot of money and fine, you know, let's not sort of deal with that issue because it might get messy. We saw as I said, 1989 the beer orders and sometimes when you come in and you do change things, you don't get what you wanted. So, you know, I can appreciate people also want to be careful.
It's why we as an organisation haven't come up with a solution. I've had sort of members push back and say, you know, you've done your beer report and you've said X and Y and Z broken, but you've not actually said what needs to be fixed. And I said, Well, yeah, we've been very careful about that. Let's start with fully understanding the problem. And I think it's not fully understood until we get sort of a proper review of that, this should be, because then you're seeing it from all the different sides. and you know, you don't run before you can walk with that. So yeah, we just really hope that.
this can be prioritised more because I think we're at a point where we are seeing that managed decline become I think there is a threat of terminal decline. Because if the picture as it is continues and we all sort of say, well, there's competing priorities and it's not as important right now, there's a scenario in so many years' time where the pubs that are left are very homogenous. they're all serving one of maybe three or four global brands.
And then they might be serving a couple of other brands that they bought up, and they still pretend they're craft and they've got a nice colourful logo, and that's for the certain, you know, the young demographic market, and then they've got their big global cask for the the older market and whatever it might be. And it's all done into these very carefully planned marketing segments. And the only breweries that survive are, you know, Carlsberg, because they bought everyone, and so there's a couple of the others, and that's about it. And then someone in government goes,
Yeah, but when I go down to my local, it still is only so and so a pint. And you know, on my road there's a pub serving two or three different brands and so there is competition and and all that sort of stuff. So it's fine, isn't it? And we all go, No, but we lost the opportunity to fix it. I think we're getting towards maybe some of the final opportunities to fix things. As Andy said, there is demand out there, but that demand won't stay if we keep going down the course we're going. It will drift off because demand
that is unsatisfied doesn't just stick there. People drift off, they'll stop going down the pub, they'll stop drinking the cask beers, they'll stop drinking quality independent beers. The brewers all shut up shop because they can't sell. And we end up in that horrible world and someone says, Yeah, but the market told us this and that's it.
Martin (47:58)
Yeah, it's the increase in micro
pubs rising.
Andy Slee (48:02)
Yeah, yes, it is.
Martin (48:02)
So this.
Andy Slee (48:03)
Brewery Taprooms. So there's been a big rise because access to market is so challenging. The number of brewers with their own taproom is rising. I find it very difficult for a brewer just to maintain a livelihood from sales to local pubs. Yeah, absolutely. I would.
Martin (48:21)
selling beer. Yeah, need to have that tap room nowadays.
Andy Slee (48:26)
Yeah, 100 percent. I would go further, Ash, and say I actually think that
cask beer, particularly given the Marstons announcement, I think cask beer is under more threat now than at any point since CAMRA was formed in 1971. and actually it's the opportunity for CAMRA in particular to redouble their efforts and return to that original focus of cask beer and looking at the different things that they can do to support that and bring that bring that to life, whether it's the sort of
the heritage status, whether it's a conversation about hand pulled taps and ownership of hand pulled taps. I think that could potentially be it's a really galvanizing point for the whole organisation, you're still the biggest single issue consumer group in Europe. And with that brings an enormous amount of strength and a great voice, which MPs.
and regulators listen to if they're of coordinated. I think that's not understating the importance of what we're talking about here. We're at a really critical point in the whole debate.
Ash Corbett-Collins (49:43)
Yeah, I completely agree. It's it's one of the things when I took over as chairman a couple of years ago, I wanted us to have more bite. Because going back to that example of every time a 1p off beer was announced in the budget, our official statement would be something along the lines of, yeah, we're we are grateful to have received that, you know, we think the government should do a little bit more. And it just didn't feel like we were doing much. You're right, we we've got a huge amount of strength. And really what I think I see CAMRA's position in this is first and foremost is education.
I think you don't know the battle you're fighting until everyone knows it, until that information is out there. I need not only some of the more involved volunteers of CAMRA to understand, but I need every volunteer in CAMRA to understand. I need all the British pub goers, all millions and millions of them to understand that they're being deceived, that they're not being given free opportunity, that the market is being undermined. If they understand that, and I think we are at a turning point in that, because five years ago, ten years ago, when announcements about breweries closing,
The vast majority of public sort of reaction was, Yeah, well, you know, bad breweries closed, bad pubs closed, but the market sort of dictates that. And if they want to, you know, they should innovate, they should change, it should be better. But I see it very differently now. The reaction from people is, no, this isn't right. Yes, we understand that actually conditions are being created that cause the undermining of this. So I think we are shifting people's understanding. And once we've done that, yeah, CAMRA absolutely needs to be using our strength as representing not just 140,000 members, but
millions of pub goers across the country and beer lovers, that we are not going to allow this to happen quietly. And you know, at the minute, as we talked about that access to market, things like that, we're waiting, we'll listen, you know, they've said they're gonna look at stuff. But if the result of that isn't good enough, then yeah, we can't just moan into our beers down the pub. We need to take direct action to to combat that.
Martin (51:31)
It's just like, how long
are you prepared to wait for this review before you start taking, you know, bigger steps?
Ash Corbett-Collins (51:37)
the it yeah, it it that is, you know, that's the
that's the million dollar question, isn't it? Because you don't you don't want to ruin relationships with decision makers. and this is the point I often have with members and they discuss with me and they say, you CAMRA should doing more. And what they don't see is that the amount of times people like Andy and me and we've got staff and and senior volunteers and we're all meeting with MPs and ministers and having conversations and we're getting people to write to their MPs.
There is so much of that happening under the surface, but it isn't headline stuff. You can't really make a news story out of the fact that you've had a conversation. It's only when you get the outcome you want that you get to say, oh it's because of all the work we did. so you know, there's so much happening under the surface, and you don't want to sort of blow that up and say, Well, actually, we're going to be very angry and and sort of shout at you because then those people might not pick up the phone. At the minute, we do have a very good relationship. You know, we get the phone picked up to us, they ring us and say, We're gonna review this.
What do you think? Come and have a meeting with us, you know, come down to to London, have that call, have that conversation. We're getting, you know, MPs will come to us and ask directly, what should I be saying to the ministers or even the prime minister when I speak to, you know, people like Jacob Collier about Marstons. So it is positive. You don't want to threaten that, but at the same time, you don't want to be seen as placated and allowed to, you know, as long as they give us a little bit of crumbs every so often, we'll just keep being nice and saying nice things about the government or any other decision making. So
Martin (53:04)
You don't want
to be seen as a pushover basically.
Ash Corbett-Collins (53:06)
Yeah,
and yes that's the careful balance because I think there are much smaller organisations and groups and campaigners who who are maybe shoutier and budgets come out and then I see the graphics and they say, effing this and isn't it terrible and I think a year ago was it at the last budget when a few publicans said, we're banning Rachel Reeves from our pub which great. It it generated
Martin (53:27)
Yeah. oh
Ash Corbett-Collins (53:28)
a few Facebook pages and headlines and people pressed like
But no actual decisions were made on the back of that. Rachel Reeves didn't go my god, I'm banned from 10 pubs. I better change my budget decisions. So
Andy Slee (53:39)
I'm
passionate of the view that any solution will always start with a conversation. So when all that happened, we turned it on its head and said, actually, Rachel Reeves is welcome in any of our taprooms across the land, as long as she gives us half an hour to explain the facts of life. Because that's what was required at the time. Shouting at people...
into avoid rarely, rarely works. And when I see some of the extreme responses on social media, effing this and whatever, it doesn't get response. Sitting down and talking to people with a fact-based arguments gets results.
Martin (54:21)
Yeah,
nine times out of 10, it dilutes the kind of information that you're trying to get across as well, doesn't it? Because, you know, not everyone
Andy Slee (54:26)
Absolutely.
Martin (54:27)
has the correct information needed. They just shout and that's it. And then everyone kind of thinks, that must be true. And it's not true. it's, you know,
Ash Corbett-Collins (54:34)
And it gets
presented, then it changes the presentation. It becomes this emotional thing. It becomes this, well, and I think the public at large then get to dismiss it because it's well, you know, they're just acting out of emotion and you know they've they've not presented anything to change my mind, and they've not present anything to change the government's mind, and it's not very good. Andy's right, you have to have those conversations. You have to have frank conversations, it has to be, you know, very honest. and I think as well, the benefit is these conversations that we do have that are behind closed doors.
gives you that opportunity. I've been sat opposite ministers and senior civil servants and been frank and honest about what we think the problems are in the industry, maybe more so than I would say in public, because there's some things you can't quite say in public at certain points. But you can then get behind that door either side of a desk and you say, no, I disagree with you fundamentally because of evidence A, evidence B, evidence C, and then hope they listen because you're valuing them as a decision maker, you're respecting them and they are respecting you.
as an industry expert and a speaker on behalf of Brewers, Publicans, Pub Goers whoever it might be.
Martin (55:35)
Yeah, definitely. And which we're gonna end it on the final question, which is, you know, what can ordinary drinkers that might be listening right now, what's the simple thing that they can do to help independent beer local pubs? You know, get that information across to them? What would you say to them to help them, you know, the access with market review, to try and get the government to listen a bit more?
What can they do as drinkers?
Andy Slee (56:04)
Go and ask your publican for your favourite independent beer. So why can't I buy it? And if you stimulate the demand on that and then equally any campaign CAMRA, Ash is organising when you get to it, give that your full support and lean into it. Don't leave it for somebody else. there's a 140,000 voices.
in CAMRA, that's 140,000 votes in constituencies and postcodes along the line. So don't leave it to somebody else. Become involved.
Ash Corbett-Collins (56:42)
I think that's right. I I had a meeting with my local MP not that long ago. you know, went along. I said I'm a constituent, I'm also, you chairman of CAMRA and welcome to the office. And he's a a fairly experienced MP, he's been around for a while. And the way he spoke made it very clear to me, and there's nothing wrong with this, but made it very clear to me how his mind works and clearly how the minds of MPs and cabinet ministers and all this sort of thing work. Because what he said was I presented all CAMRA's positions, I presented what my concerns were.
And he turned around and he said, Okay, how many breweries are there in my constituency? How many pubs? Which pubs can't get this access to market? Which breweries are struggling? How many CAMRA members are there in my constituency? Everything he wanted, a quantity of. He wanted to understand, as Andy said, you know, how many votes are there in this? What is it affecting? How much money does it make in my constituency? what actual direct impact does this have on me as an MP and on my local area? And so this is when, you know.
Even just simple things like emailing your MP and people say you know, I was emailing my MP and I don't get anything. But if they see every single time that this matter comes up, they're getting a volume of emails that to them they can't ignore because it represents votes, particularly if you're in a constituency where votes are on the edge and it matters, they will listen. And it might not be the first time, might not be the second time. And even though they're supposed to email you back, I've had experience of MPs emailing me back when I've lived in different constituencies, it happens.
But if you keep going at them, if everyone else keeps going at them and it's and if it's happening from the under side of the bar, as Andy says, if you're going into your pubs and saying to them, I'd like to be able to purchase certain beers and and asking them why the situation is what it is, and then they're talking to their regional reps or the you know the pub co, whatever it might be, and feeding back the consumer demand, we've got to push with strength in all the directions. And it's only when we demonstrate that this is a matter that is important to a lot of people to all decision makers, will they start to take it seriously.
the big one is in this country, people always say that animal charities are the biggest charities. They they absolutely outstrip all other charities in this country, I think it is. You know, we absolutely love our animals in this country. We're batty for them. But that is then represented in decision making because those charities are huge and they can, you know, go and make decisions and get things done. And, you know, that's why we have actually some quite strong animal protection laws in this country, because people told decision makers 100, 200 years ago, this is what they care about.
We've got to do the same thing for beer, which sounds a bit facetious, but if we demonstrate that a 140,000, if three million pub goers, whatever it might be, are not just going to let this quietly happen, decision makers will sit up and start listening.
Martin (59:18)
Yeah. And what about for people that who are not very confident in, emailing their local MP because they don't feel like they have the correct information. Is there anything you can do as an organisation to kind of give them like a broad template of questions with facts and figures that can help them?
Ash Corbett-Collins (59:35)
Yeah, so we we do that every time we have a campaign. It's always, you know, and these aren't just for our members. So we always email all our members and say, please can you just press this button and email your your MP and we've got a system, all you have to do is you put your name, your address and your telephone number in, because those are the things that are required when you email an MP, and it sends it out on your behalf. You then have the option to edit that, and I always do, and I always make sure I edit the first paragraph because that's the bit they notice if they're getting the same thing. I always edit the first paragraph.
And then but you know, because I've got these years of experience, I always try to tailor it to a local thing. I'll say this is affecting for example my constituency, Leviathan Brewery. Fantastic little brewery. And I you know, that's what this support would help with. And just make sure that they're always getting that local angle. But that's open to absolutely everyone. If they go on our social media or go on our website anytime around the budget, or if they see it on our posts and we're saying about something we're campaigning about, anyone in the country can click on the link and get involved in that and do it that way. So that that's always important to us. And if people
you know, aren't comfortable with that, and maybe, you know, don't want to put their head above the parapet, that's absolutely fine. I get it. What I'd ask those people to do is, you know, try and learn for themselves. Again, resources on our website, I'm sure SIBA have got on their website and just, you know, speaking to people. If I could ask them to do one thing, it's to tell someone else. If you've got a friend who's also a pubgoer or a beer drinker, bring it up over a beer at some point and just say, did you know?
The reason that on the bar we've only got XYZ Global Brewer and they all cost this much is this. And it still surprises me now the amount of people I'll have that conversation with. Like, oh, I didn't realise it was like that. So
Martin (1:01:09)
Yeah.
Ash Corbett-Collins (1:01:09)
even if you've told one person. And if every one person tells one person, we double the amount of people who know what's going on. And that for me, that conversation over a beer would be fantastic.
Andy Slee (1:01:19)
I reckon, of all pubgoers, we always quote the fact there's about two thirds of beer drinkers don't give a damn about any of this stuff. Actually, you know, they're quite, quite happy with, you know, a global brand at a certain price. But there's about a third that do that. And those that do are really bothered. They're really, really bothered. And they're more
Martin (1:01:44)
I shouldn't.
Andy Slee (1:01:44)
likely to be going, yeah, they're passionate about it.
They're likely to be going to the pub more often and they're likely to be spending more money. So and that's the that's the people we need to appeal to. And one third of all pubgoers is a lot. It's a lot of people. if Ash's right, it's however you do it, just don't keep it to yourself and just don't don't let your mate around the corner. Don't leave it to somebody else. You know, get involved yourself however you feel comfortable.
Martin (1:02:11)
Yeah, definitely. Even if it's a conversation with your mate, just explaining the tied beer lines. Yeah, so I think we're end it on that. It was a lovely conversation. And thank you very much both you for coming on.
Andy Slee (1:02:23)
Pleasure.
Martin (1:02:24)
anyone, if you got a quick message you want to give to our listeners before we go?
Andy Slee (1:02:29)
Ash?
Ash Corbett-Collins (1:02:31)
I was gonna comment the fact you said a lovely conversation. one day I really hope I do a podcast where we're talking about how amazing the beer industry is and wasn't it great when we achieved
Andy Slee (1:02:39)
Yeah.
Ash Corbett-Collins (1:02:39)
X and and isn't it gonna be that that's that that's my dream. We do
Martin (1:02:41)
then there'd be no job for me then.
Andy Slee (1:02:43)
Yeah.
Ash Corbett-Collins (1:02:45)
thrive on that sort of you know, there has to be something negative down there to sort of. But yeah, I d love that that's what I do. I think I'd like to just end it on we've talked about it being existential. I've said words like terminal. That's not inevitable is the other word I'd like to use.
Martin (1:03:00)
Yeah, it's not the only route that's gonna happen.
Ash Corbett-Collins (1:03:00)
I liken it to the climate crisis. Yeah. And I think
some people, you know, it almost feels overwhelming and we talked about global brewers, we talked about governments, we talked about wars in the Middle East. Like we talked about all the things that as a single pub goer you probably feel like you can't do anything about and little old me just wants to have my beer and isn't this terrible? But there's nothing I can do. But it's not inevitable.
We have seen changes in the past. So I talked about micro pubs and you know, when that planning was changing, we just saw an explosion in those. When the the small brewers relief came in and we saw the explosion of small brewers around this country. So the you know, to amazing numbers. If good things happen and decisions are made, things can change. Much more for the positive. And and yeah, you know, I do genuinely think that we could in six, twelve months' time actually be doing this podcast where we talk about, well, the access to market review came out and everyone emailed their MP
and and
you know, and it's resulted in real change and the the guest beer right was done correctly and it's resulting real change. So don't feel overwhelmed. The the ending point for me is we can do with this. We've just got to all kinda push together in the right direction.
Martin (1:04:01)
Yeah,
we've got to come together as one.
Andy Slee (1:04:03)
My message
is, I'm really confident about the future for independent beer because I know there's demand there. anybody watching listening to this, if you're in a pub, for your local independent beer in whatever format it's on and support them because they will appreciate your custom and it will allow them to survive and thrive. And in the meantime, thanks for their custom to date and thanks for their interest.
Because without that interest, independent brewers don't have a living. We wouldn't be about.
Martin (1:04:37)
Yeah, definitely. That's lovely. Yeah. So go and support your local independent breweries. Ask your local landlord why you haven't got an independent local beer on and what one you'd like on. And on that note, we'll catch you again in a couple of weeks. And thank you again once for Ash and Andy for coming on the show.
Andy Slee (1:04:58)
Pleasure.
Martin (1:04:59)
Welcome and we'll see you again soon. Cheers. Bye bye.
Chairman, CAMRA
Ash has been a CAMRA Director since 2018, and Chairman since September 2024.
Born and raised in Burton-on-Trent, Ash joined CAMRA at Burton Beer Festival in 2011, by which point he had already developed a love for pubs and cask beer. He now lives in Birmingham with his wife Jess, their dog, and a large collection of vintage football shirts.
Apple Podcasts
Spotify
Amazon Music
Youtube Music